15 Things I Wish I Knew Before Visiting LONG ISLAND, New York (2026)
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Shelter Island Ferries ▶ 0:00
The presenter explains that two short cash-only ferries through Shelter Island turn an hour and a quarter of driving into thirty minutes, and that the crossing is easy but you shouldn't do it twice in a day.
- Riverhead ▶ 0:31
Past Riverhead, about three quarters of the way out, Long Island stops being one thing and splits into the North Fork and the South Fork.
- Greenport ▶ 1:04
The main town on the north side, where the North Ferry departs; the presenter recommends booking here on the North Fork for its working harbor, restaurants, waterfront carousel and ferry dock in the middle of town.
- Montauk ▶ 1:36
Sitting at the very tip of the island, about three hours from Manhattan on a clear weekday and five on a summer Friday; beautiful and priced accordingly.
- Montauk Lighthouse ▶ 1:53
The lighthouse closes in the late afternoon and turns away visitors who have just driven three hours to stand in front of it.
- Patchogue ▶ 3:05
Take the train to Patchogue, walk five minutes to the ferry terminal, and you're at Watch Hill thirty minutes later.
- Watch Hill ▶ 3:05
The best of the car-free days out, reached by ferry from Patchogue; no cars are allowed anywhere on Fire Island.
- Ocean Beach ▶ 3:21
If you'd rather have restaurants and bars around you, the Bay Shore ferries go to Ocean Beach instead.
- Sailors Haven and Sunken Forest ▶ 3:21
The Sayville boat lands at Sailors Haven, which is the one with the Sunken Forest behind it.
- Long Beach Boardwalk ▶ 3:21
Long Beach is the second walkable day out, a boardwalk town on the same railway, and the boardwalk has never cost anything.
- Huntington ▶ 3:36
One of the walkable north shore villages and a value base, sitting on a harbor, cheaper and an hour closer to the city than anything out east.
- Northport ▶ 3:36
One of the two north shore names that come up again and again, walkable and on a harbor, considerably cheaper than the East End.
- Port Jefferson ▶ 3:36
The third walkable north shore village, with one warning locals repeat: the waterfront is lovely to walk and poor to swim because the bottom drops away fast.
- Sag Harbor ▶ 4:12
The presenter's pick for the South Fork: an old whaling port, the least Hamptons-looking part of the Hamptons, with a main street of actual shops, walkable end to end in twenty minutes.
- Coopers Beach ▶ 7:31
Named the best beach in America in 2025 by coastal scientist Stephen Leatherman; visitors can park by the day for a fee that goes up every season.
- Main Beach ▶ 7:50
Came fifth on the same best-beach list, 12 miles away; non-resident season permits are capped and sell on a set date, and the day permit is Monday through Thursday.
- Jones Beach State Park ▶ 8:22
One of the state parks that solves the beach-permit problem because it takes anybody, and it's covered by the $80 Empire Pass.
- Robert Moses State Park ▶ 8:22
Listed among the state parks that take anybody, covered by the Empire Pass for day-use vehicle entry.
- Hither Hills State Park ▶ 8:22
The state park out at Montauk that takes anybody, covered by the Empire Pass.
- Orient Beach State Park ▶ 8:22
The state park at the northeastern tip of the island, one of the ones that takes anybody.
- Camp Hero State Park ▶ 8:22
Right at the end of the island, a state park built around a rusting Cold War radar antenna, a curved steel lattice the size of a house on a concrete bunker, covered by the Empire Pass.
- Sagamore Hill ▶ 9:29
Theodore Roosevelt's house from 1885 until he died in it in 1919; the grounds, trails, marsh walk to his beach and orchard museum are free, while the house is guided tour only with tickets released at 9:30 that morning.
- Caumsett State Historic Park Preserve ▶ 9:29
The former Marshall Field estate, now a state park with five miles of trail, a beach and 20-foot bluffs over the Sound; bring a bike because the parking lot is far from the water.
- Meadow Lane ▶ 10:06
Locals call it Billionaire's Row, but driving it you'll mostly see green because the houses sit behind 20-foot privet hedges and gates.
- Further Lane ▶ 10:23
Driving Further Lane in East Hampton, like Lily Pond Lane, you'll see more green than houses thanks to the hedges.
- Lily Pond Lane ▶ 10:23
Another East Hampton lane where the enormous houses are hidden behind hedges, so the slow drive past wealth mostly shows greenery.
- Old Montauk Highway ▶ 10:54
Take the old road for the last stretch into Montauk rather than staying on 27, because it runs along the ocean side and the new one doesn't.
- Planting Fields Arboretum ▶ 12:59
Puts a 65-room Tudor manor in the middle of an arboretum and wants about an hour.
- Vanderbilt Museum ▶ 12:59
Wants half a day because there's a planetarium bolted onto the mansion, and people who arrive for the house end up staying for the show.
- Old Westbury Gardens ▶ 13:16
One of the Gold Coast estates that fills out the same day if the weather holds.
- Sands Point Preserve ▶ 13:16
Another Gold Coast stop that fills out the same day if the weather holds.
- Cold Spring Harbor Whaling Museum ▶ 13:16
The whaling museum at Cold Spring Harbor fills out the same Gold Coast day if the weather holds.
- Cradle of Aviation Museum ▶ 13:16
The rainy-day option, home to Lunar Module 13, built to fly Apollo 18 before the mission was cancelled; Grumman built the lunar modules half an hour up the road in Bethpage.
- King Umberto's ▶ 14:25
The pizza name that came up most, from five separate people, open since 1976.
- Little Vincent's ▶ 14:41
The one pizzeria behind the cold slice, hot pizza with cold shredded cheese piled on top so it melts while you eat; plenty of lifelong locals have never heard of it.
- Little Creek Oysters ▶ 14:57
The lunch spot in Greenport for oysters.
- Gosman's Dock ▶ 14:57
The lunch and dinner spot out at Montauk, on the water.
- Peter's Clam Bar ▶ 14:57
The clam bar over in Island Park, named among the places where lunch and dinner belong on the water.
- Lunch (the lobster roll stand) ▶ 14:57
The lobster roll everyone names sits on the Napeague stretch between Amagansett and Montauk, at a place whose sign just reads LUNCH.
- Briermere Farms ▶ 15:15
The famous pie stop near Riverhead on Sound Avenue, though opinion has split lately between people who say it's unchanged and people who figure it's living off the name.
- Lewin Farms ▶ 15:15
The unglamorous alternative to Briermere, where you get handed a bag and pointed at the apples.
- Croteaux Vineyards ▶ 15:35
Makes rosé and nothing else, the only vineyard in the country doing that, and because it doesn't sell to shops the tasting garden is the only way to drink it.
- Crescent Duck Farm ▶ 15:35
The reason Long Island duck is on menus at all; it lost its entire flock of around 100,000 birds to avian flu in January 2025, then rebuilt from its own eggs once the quarantine lifted in May.
- Great South Bay ▶ 17:04
The flat, calm-looking stretch between the mainland and Fire Island that locals actually avoid, because it doesn't flush the way the Sound does; cross the bridge and swim in the ocean instead.
- North Fork ▶ 17:39
If forced to cut the trip to a single day, the presenter would take the North Fork: a bacon egg and cheese, farm stands down both sides of the road, oysters in a working harbor, then the ferry to Shelter Island as the light goes.
Cities in these videos
Shelter Island · Riverhead · Greenport · Montauk · Patchogue · Fire Island · Long Beach · Huntington · Northport · Port Jefferson · Sag Harbor · Southampton · East Hampton · Wantagh · Babylon · Orient · Oyster Bay · Lloyd Harbor · Centerport · Old Westbury · Sands Point · Cold Spring Harbor · Garden City · New Hyde Park · Island Park · Calverton · Southold · Aquebogue · Long Island