COMPLETE NYC Sandwich Guide 2025 (Pastrami, Deli Sandwiches, Burgers, Bagels, and Hot Dogs!)
Jon Barr ·
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Pastrami Queen ▶ 0:15
A tiny Upper East Side deli the host calls a sleeper pick, famous for its pastrami sandwich that Anthony Bourdain loved. They rate it 7.35.
- Second Avenue Deli ▶ 2:41
A classic New York deli now in Midtown East, opened in 2007, keeping alive the tradition of the original owner Abe Lebewohl. They try the pastrami and rate it 8.1.
- Sarge's Deli ▶ 6:28
Opened in 1964 by a retired NYC police sergeant, this local favorite has a huge diner-style menu. Its juicy pastrami sandwich wins the pastrami ranking with 8.9.
- Katz's Delicatessen ▶ 8:53
New York's oldest deli, open since 1888, famous for thick hand-sliced pastrami and its 'send a salami to your boy in the army' slogan. They rate it 8.0.
- BK Jani ▶ 13:42
A Pakistani restaurant in Bushwick serving a famous Halal burger with mint chutney and raita, plus lamb chops. The owner tells how he built the best Halal burger in the city.
- Emily ▶ 26:11
A Brooklyn pizzeria whose Emmy Burger on a pretzel bun with Korean gochujang sauce became a viral sensation. They watch it made and try it.
- Jubilee Marketplace ▶ 32:51
A Greenpoint market with a butcher shop downstairs selling $2.55 smash burger sliders inspired by White Mana in New Jersey.
- David's Brisket House ▶ 40:36
A halal, kosher-style deli in Brooklyn serving pastrami, brisket and corned beef in multiple sizes. The host calls it a sleeper pick for the best cured meats.
- Defonte's ▶ 46:27
An old-school Italian deli in Red Hook open over 100 years, popular with firefighters and police. They try the Golden Boy and the Chenzo 13 sandwiches by the waterfront.
- Farmer in the Deli ▶ 50:42
A Brooklyn deli that chops your sandwich together with chips on the counter, a social media hit. They order the chopped turkey roll.
- Absolute Bagels ▶ 54:14
A cash-only bagel institution in Morningside Heights with long lines of Columbia students. The host calls it the best bagel he's ever had in New York City.
- Billy's Hot Dog Cart ▶ 56:24
A legendary hot dog cart near Central Park run by Billy for over 30 years, known for its onion sauce and neighborhood feel.
- Central Park ▶ 58:04
The host takes Billy's hot dogs to eat in Central Park, noting the location is perfect to combine with the cart.
- Nathan's Famous ▶ 1:01:45
The original Coney Island hot dog stand where the hot dog was invented, at Surf and Stillwell Avenue. The host finds it overpriced and touristy.
- Essa Bagel ▶ 1:04:23
A famous bagel shop open since 1976 with several Manhattan locations, known for big doughy bagels and lots of cream cheese.
- Gray's Papaya ▶ 1:05:26
The last remaining tropical hot dog shop, known for cheap hot dog deals and a $3 breakfast special.
- Russ & Daughters ▶ 1:06:30
A 110-year-old Lower East Side appetizing institution famous for Nova salmon and lox, though the host notes the bagels aren't made in house.
- Smacking Burger ▶ 1:07:32
A smash burger spot inside a gas station in the West Village, serving the Big Smack, Oklahoma burger and loaded fries.
- Blue Hour ▶ 1:11:23
A halal food counter hidden inside a Bushwick gas station serving chicken over rice, a Crunch Wrap knockoff and the Crown Jewel Italian sandwich.
- Donovan's Pub ▶ 1:16:29
An old-school Irish pub in Woodside since the 1960s, famous for its juicy chuck, steak and brisket burger and its Salvador Dalí art collection.
- Chimito ▶ 1:21:01
A Corona spot dedicated to the Dominican chimichurri sandwich, with ten varieties on a toasted Portuguese roll.
- Prontito ▶ 1:27:24
A Colombian fast food spot in Elmhurst famous for its extravagant arepa burger with bacon, quail egg, potato chips and pineapple sauce.
- Le Gigot ▶ 1:32:10
A classic French restaurant that serves only 12 brisket burgers per day at the bar, topped with St Andre cheese and watercress.
- East Way Gourmet ▶ 1:35:10
A typical New York bodega where they get a classic bacon, egg and cheese on a roll with ketchup.
- Tompkins Square Bagels ▶ 1:38:36
An East Village bagel shop open since 2011 with dozens of cream cheese flavors and wild bagels like French toast and rainbow. They try a bacon egg and cheese on a French toast bagel.
- Golden Diner ▶ 1:41:33
A social media sensation diner serving a $17 Chinatown egg and cheese sandwich with soft scrambled eggs, hash brown and a scallion milk bun.
- Utopia Bagels ▶ 1:46:14
A Whitestone, Queens bagel shop open since 1981 making 10,000+ hand-rolled bagels a day in a 1947 oven. The host calls them possibly the best in the city.
- Joey Roses ▶ 2:03:22
A retro dive bar owned by comedian Joe DeRosa with $3 beers and $10 Italian sandwiches like the Rosie and the Dad.
- Nowon ▶ 2:07:46
New York's first Korean American gastro pub, serving a legendary smash burger with kimchi and sesame buns. The host calls it close to a 10 out of 10.
- 7th Street Burger ▶ 2:12:20
A cult smash burger chain that started on 7th Street, with a tiny menu of cheeseburgers, grilled onions and house sauce.
- Lexington Candy Shop ▶ 2:15:17
The city's oldest running family luncheonette, open since 1925, serving a butter burger, old-fashioned Coke floats and egg creams.
- Dat's Deli ▶ 2:20:28
A Hollis, Queens deli that went viral for its oxtail mac patty and other West Indian patty sandwiches wrapped in coco bread.
- Chris and Charlie's ▶ 2:24:43
A legendary old-school deli in Astoria known as the Sandwich King, serving a massive 3-pound sandwich with every cold cut imaginable.
- Notable ▶ 2:27:40
A new-school Astoria spot doing Jamaican fusion sandwiches like the jerk chicken and oxtail Philly on coco bread.
- Santa Salsa ▶ 2:34:25
A Bushwick spot serving Venezuelan street hot dogs loaded with cabbage, chips, sauces and wasakaka, plus vegan options.
- Dog Day Afternoon ▶ 2:38:18
A Chicago-style hot dog shop in Brooklyn named after the Al Pacino film, with steamed Vienna Beef dogs and neon relish.
- Red Hook Food Corp ▶ 2:42:00
A Red Hook bodega run by General O, a TikTok sensation, famous for the Aki Way bacon egg and cheese with a honey bun and mozzarella sticks.
- Sunny and Annie's Deli ▶ 2:45:52
A Korean-owned deli in Alphabet City known for outrageous sandwiches like the Jackie Chan with bulgogi and the Thai-inspired Fall sandwich.
- Harlem Taste ▶ 2:48:34
Formerly Hajji's Blue Sky Deli, credited with inventing the chopped cheese sandwich in the 1990s. They try the original chopped cheese on a hero.
- Peter McManus Cafe ▶ 3:00:51
A family-run Irish pub open since 1936 in Chelsea, serving a Reuben sandwich and the Pop Pops burger.
- Doo's Italian Sandwich Society ▶ 3:03:49
New York's only Italian deli on wheels, a food truck serving huge sandwiches like the Big Paulie, Carmine and the secret Don Fucci.
- All'Antico Vinaio ▶ 3:09:42
The Florence sandwich shop's fifth New York location, serving Tuscan schiacciata sandwiches like La Favolosa and La Paradiso.
- John's Deli ▶ 3:18:27
A South Brooklyn deli established in 1968, famous for the Johnny Roast Beef sandwich swimming in gravy.
- Roland's Roast ▶ 3:21:31
A nostalgic roast beef spot open since 1970 where you can spin a wheel on your birthday, serving roast beef with cheese whiz.
- Brennan & Carr ▶ 3:24:02
Established in 1938, the oldest spot in the video, serving hot roast beef sandwiches dipped in gravy, known as a knife-and-fork job.
- Murray's Bagels ▶ 3:33:11
A Greenwich Village bagel shop used as the New York sample in a New York vs Montreal bagel comparison.
- Fairmount Bagel ▶ 3:36:39
One of Montreal's most famous bagel shops, known for smaller, denser, honey-boiled sesame bagels with a big hole.