Ranking Jacksonville's Best Pizza Part 2!
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Electric Dough Pizza Co. ▶ 0:31
The first stop of day two, a new spot from James Beard-nominated chef Tom Gray doing a cross between Detroit and Roman style pizza. They try the Godfather deep dish and praise its crispy edges, pillowy center and high-end ingredients.
- Rodrigo's Pizza ▶ 5:30
A Neapolitan-style spot where they order a margherita with pepperoni and a Bella pie. They rave about the depth of flavor, the leopard-spotted crust and the 5-7 day fermented dough, later naming it the best pizza in Jacksonville.
- Moon River Pizza ▶ 10:34
A long-time neighborhood favorite in Murray Hill. They find it a solid, classic American slice but soggy and greasy, though they say they'd stop in for a slice if in the area.
- Joseph's Pizza ▶ 13:00
Established in 1956, the oldest pizzeria in the city, packed with a crowd. They call it a solid, consistent American-style pizza and note the vintage bread advertisement found behind the wall during a renovation.
- Crispy's ▶ 16:00
A Springfield neighborhood spot under new ownership, where they try a big-pepperoni New York-style pie. They find it a massive improvement over five years ago and a contender for the top ten.
- Carmine's Pie House ▶ 19:06
Stop 21, where they try a Chicago-style deep dish. They love the sauce, cheese and pepperoni but find the crust too soft, doughy and lacking structure.
- Joe Baba Pizzeria ▶ 21:37
A walk-up pizza window attached to Mudville Grill, open only eight weeks and across from Bishop Kenny High School. They call it an approachable, greasy bar pizza that's great with a game and a beer.
- Pie 95 ▶ 26:30
The winner of their previous best-pizza list, doing wood-fired neo-Neapolitan pizza with long-fermented dough in a 1927 building. They interview the owner about the dough and wood oven and find the pizza even better than before.
- Vito's Pizza ▶ 40:05
Mentioned as an honorable mention on Monument Road in Arlington, beloved and recommended by many, but closed because the Italian owners were on vacation in Italy.
- Pizza Point ▶ 42:54
An honorable mention known for incredible Indian-flavored pizzas that the group absolutely loved but couldn't fit on the list.
- Mama's Killer Pizza ▶ 43:10
Ranked number ten, a pizza place with an owner from Brooklyn whose mac and cheese pie they say will rock your world.
- Pizza Dynamo ▶ 43:41
Ranked number seven, praised for its New York-style slice and the grandma pie, with a recommendation to try the Stretch Stella.
- Bones Pizza ▶ 43:58
Ranked number six, located inside Red Brewing Company, doing a fantastic Neapolitan-style pizza.
- Venice Pizza ▶ 44:15
Ranked number five, on Beach Boulevard, making one of the best classic pies you'll ever want to eat.
- Picasso's ▶ 44:51
Ranked number two, known for St. Louis-style pizza with a cracker-thin crust that they say will rock your world.