Orkney: Cruise Crowds, Ferry Timings & Who Should Skip It
Phil and H Travel Podcast - Is It Worth It? ·
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Orkney ▶ 0:16
The podcast dissects Orkney's overtourism paradox: 213,785 cruise passengers a year against a population of 21,920, harbor dues trapped in the wrong budget, and no toilets at its most famous stone circle.
- Ring of Brodgar ▶ 6:56
The podcast highlights the Ring of Brodgar as one of the most spectacular ancient sites, but notes it has no toilet because harbor money can't be spent on tourist infrastructure. It is free, unstaffed and open at any hour, making it the best place to escape cruise crowds at dawn.
- Broch of Gurness ▶ 11:14
Described as Orkney's premier Iron Age village, it is open from 1 April to 30 September and closed entirely from October through March. Entry is £7.50 and it scores 4.8 from 362 reviews.
- Bishop's and Earl's Palaces ▶ 11:27
The ruined palaces across from the cathedral follow the same six-month closure schedule as the Broch of Gurness. They rate 4.1 from over 300 reviews and the upper level of the Moosie Tower is currently closed.
- Stones of Stenness ▶ 11:37
The chambered cairn at Stenness drops from four guided tours a day in summer to three in winter. The standing stones themselves are free, unstaffed and open all year, scoring 4.5.
- Italian Chapel ▶ 11:43
The chapel reduces its hours to just three a day from November to March compared to 8.5 hours in midsummer. Entry is £4 and it scores 4.6 from over 1,200 reviews.
- Broad Street ▶ 12:37
Broad Street in front of the Market Cross hosts the Ba, Kirkwall's chaotic traditional street football game played on Christmas Day and New Year's Day, with the men's game starting at 1pm.
- Market Cross ▶ 12:38
The men's Ba game starts at 1pm on Broad Street in front of the Market Cross on Christmas Day and New Year's Day.
- Stromness ▶ 19:33
Stromness is where the Scrabster ferry lands and puts you about 20 minutes from the major stone circles, making it a good base for exploring the West Mainland.
- Kirkwall ▶ 19:44
Kirkwall is the main town, with the cathedral, the museum, the only bank, the main bus hubs and the Hatston Pier where the big ferries and cruise ships arrive.
- Merkister Hotel ▶ 19:59
The Merkister's rooms page was a dead link, another example of the lack of clear seasonal rate cards in Orkney.
- Stromness Hotel ▶ 20:03
The Stromness Hotel provides no rates at all and simply directs you to a third-party booking search engine.
- Ayre Hotel ▶ 20:09
The Ayre Hotel's website would not load during the research, part of the opaque Orkney accommodation market.
- Albert Hotel ▶ 20:16
The Albert Hotel only provides price floors: a standard double from £190 with breakfast, rising to £230 for a deluxe. In the level three budget it accounts for 72% of the total.
- Kirkwall Hotel ▶ 20:37
Its live booking calendar showed nightly prices ranging from £75 to £300 for the same autumn season, a four-times spread depending on the day.
- Pol Rudden Guesthouse ▶ 21:39
This Kirkwall guesthouse provides a flat rate of £70 a room with a three-night minimum and no seasonal variation, one of the few transparent options.
- Norvald ▶ 22:12
A self-catering cottage at Birsay sleeping six, with a full seasonal ladder: £875 a week in July and August dropping to £595 in winter, a 47% peak premium.
- Orkney Caravan Park ▶ 22:40
At the Pickaquoy Centre, peak adults are £15.35 a night with a grass pitch and electrics adding £6.55; camping pods are around $75 in peak season.
- Cairn o' Get ▶ 24:35
The guided cairn tour is £10 each online, and it is included in the level one and level two budget admissions.
- Skara Brae ▶ 24:45
The champion attraction, scoring 4.8 from over 2,300 reviews. Entry is £14 each and from April to October the ticket also includes Skaill House; it took in 96,000 visits in 2025.
- Broch of Birsay ▶ 24:51
The Broch of Birsay is completely free according to Historic Environment Scotland, scoring 4.7, but it is only reachable at low tide.
- Orkney Distillery ▶ 25:38
The gin distillery rates higher on TripAdvisor than either of the island's famous whisky houses.
- Albert Street ▶ 26:08
Albert Street in Kirkwall holds the Bank of Scotland's only branch in all of Orkney, open weekdays 9:30 to 3 and closed on weekends.
- St Magnus Cathedral ▶ 28:03
The cathedral is Kirkwall's main landmark, free to enter and rated 4.7 from over 2,000 reviews. The council report documents visitors walking into it during local funerals, and its upper levels tour costs about £15.
- Highland Park Distillery ▶ 32:05
The local legend tour is £75 a head, with options from a £30 welcome experience up to a rare and exclusive tour at £1,600. It scores 4.5.
- Scapa Distillery ▶ 32:05
Scapa's journey tour is £30 a head, included in the level four whisky budget.
- Maeshowe ▶ 34:46
Access is strictly by guided tour from the Stenness visitor centre, with four tours a day in summer and three in winter at £10 online. Capacity is unpublished and reviewers report tours sold out until September.
- Balfour Hospital ▶ 38:27
NHS Orkney describes the Balfour as a small rural general hospital with 48 beds, an emergency department, maternity and surgical services; specialist patients may be transferred to Aberdeen.
- Yesnaby ▶ 40:20
The official tourism site warns visitors to be careful on the unfenced coastal paths at Yesnaby, with slippery rock and loose, uneven ground. It scores 4.8 and is free.
- Marwick Head ▶ 40:33
The cliffs rise nearly 90 m with no fences or barriers; the RSPB calls the path wet and slippery with steep inclines. It carries a fine score but from just 71 reviews.
- Old Man of Hoy ▶ 41:04
The official materials conflate two routes: a 9.25 km walk from Rackwick graded two out of five, and a 21 km circular route over Cuilags graded five. There is no public transport to Rackwick.
- Churchill Barriers ▶ 41:35
These vital causeways close when easterly winds exceed 25 mph, westerly winds exceed 40 mph, or a flood warning is active, with 45 hours of closures two years ago.
- Orkney Museum ▶ 45:12
The Orkney Museum clears the bar with 4.5 and is free to enter.
- Scapa Flow Museum ▶ 45:39
The Scapa Flow Museum at Lyness clears with 4.6, free entry with a suggested £5 donation, though it closes outright for January and February.
- Skaill House ▶ 45:49
Skaill House sits at 4.1 from 505 reviews, the lowest-rated Orkney attraction with a 500-plus sample, and it is forced onto the same ticket as Skara Brae from April to October.
- Stromness Museum ▶ 46:22
Stromness Museum falls short of the review bar at 4.4.
- Ness of Brodgar ▶ 48:17
The premier live archaeology draw for a decade is permanently finished: fieldwork ended in August 2024, trenches are backfilled and the site is closed to the public.
- Tomb of the Eagles ▶ 48:43
Closed in 2021, it reopened after a local development trust took over and upgraded the visitor centre. Open 1 April to 18 October, walk-in with no booking, and visitors may still handle the original artifacts.
- Westray to Papa Westray flight ▶ 49:18
Loganair markets this as the world's shortest scheduled flight at around 90 seconds on an eight-seat Islander, but there is no listed price anywhere and the sightseer fare is telephone-only.
- Orkney Ferries ▶ 50:19
The North Isles tariff is £13.50 return for an adult and £32 for a car; the South Isles tariff is £6.90 and £22, with bicycles free on every route.
- Orkney Uncovered ▶ 50:39
The most reviewed guide service in Orkney shows no prices on its website or availability calendar, forcing a telephone call for a custom quote.
- Jarlshof ▶ 51:35
Shetland's premier site stacks 4,000 years of history from Neolithic structures to a Norse longhouse to a 16th-century laird's house, scoring 4.8 from over 500 reviews, a fifth of Skara Brae's sample.
- Up Helly Aa ▶ 51:57
Scheduled for 26 January 2027 in Lerwick, nearly a thousand torchbearers march behind the Guizer Jarl at 7:30pm and burn a replica galley, though hall access is extremely restricted.
- Luskentyre Beach ▶ 53:12
On Harris, it scores an incredible 4.9 from over 1,100 reviews, a combination of high score and massive sample size that Orkney does not possess.
- Callanish Standing Stones ▶ 53:32
The listing now resolves to Callanish Standing Stones and Visitor Centre and its rating has collapsed to 3.7 from 32 reviews, attributed to a reported £15 admission charge.
- Duncansby Head ▶ 54:47
It scores 4.8 on nearly 800 reviews and is completely free, with massive sea stacks of its own, offering the Orkney coastal drama without the ferry cost.
- Dunnet Head ▶ 55:04
Mainland Britain's most northerly point scores 4.5 on over 900 reviews; you stand on the edge of the Pentland Firth and look out at Orkney instead of paying to cross.
Cities in these videos
Orkney · Kirkwall · Stromness · Birsay · Hoy · Shetland · Lerwick · Harris · Callanish · Caithness