I Tried NYC Tourist Trap Restaurants *again*
Jon Barr ·
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Katz's Delicatessen ▶ 0:08
The presenter visits this famous Jewish deli, noting the long lines and mixed reviews, and orders the classic pastrami on rye with mustard for $28.95. He praises the moist, fatty pastrami and the communal dining experience but finds the rye bread a bit soggy.
- Sarge's Deli ▶ 1:58
The presenter compares this neighborhood Jewish deli to Katz's, noting there's no line and a more local vibe. He orders the same pastrami on rye for $28.79 and finds it juicier, more flavorful and easier to eat than Katz's, giving Sarge's the win.
- Lombardi's Pizza ▶ 7:58
The presenter visits America's first pizzeria, open since 1905, and orders the rustic double pepperoni. He's disappointed: the dough is bland, the crust cracker-like, and the shop lost its coal oven in 2020 when it moved, so the pizza lacks char.
- Arturo's Pizza ▶ 10:37
The presenter heads to this local pizzeria open since 1957, which flies under the tourist radar. He orders a $32 Margherita and loves the leopard-spotted, charred crust from its original coal oven, calling it night and day better than Lombardi's.
- Junior's ▶ 15:55
The presenter visits this famous cheesecake destination, open since 1950, and grabs a plain cheesecake slice for $9.50. He finds it dense, creamy and super rich with a spongy crust, but says it's pricey and lives off its tourist hype.
- Eileen's Special Cheesecake ▶ 17:18
The presenter visits this local cheesecake shop open since 1974, with no crowds and just cheesecake. He pays $6.50 for a mini cheesecake that's airier with a graham cracker crust, finds it easier to eat, and gives it the win over Junior's.