NYC First Timer MISTAKES To Avoid! Skip These Attractions?
Jon Barr ·
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Empire State Building ▶ 0:19
The hosts call it overrated as a pure observation deck: the bars on the deck make it hard to see, and you can't see the Empire State Building itself from inside it. They suggest Top of the Rock for a better view.
- Top of the Rock ▶ 1:18
Recommended as the better pure observation deck experience if you want the iconic view that includes the Empire State Building.
- Times Square ▶ 1:18
Jon calls it totally overrated and overcrowded, the hub of every scam, though worth visiting once; Sarah argues it's one of a kind and you have to go once for the photo.
- Statue of Liberty ▶ 2:13
Sarah says it's not overrated if you go inside the crown, one of the coolest things she's done in NYC for $24; Jon considers it overrated unless you do the crown, noting you can see it from boats.
- Ellis Island ▶ 3:23
Most Statue of Liberty visits include Ellis Island, which Sarah calls an amazing experience and part of why the trip isn't overrated.
- Madame Tussauds New York ▶ 3:41
Both hosts call it overrated: there are 30 Madame Tussauds worldwide, it's on every attraction pass and always mobbed, and you should be outside experiencing the real city instead.
- Brooklyn Bridge ▶ 4:31
Jon calls the classic walk overrated because it's always crowded and you can't see the bridge from it, suggesting the Manhattan Bridge walk instead; Sarah says the newly opened bike lane underneath makes it peaceful and worth doing by bike.
- Manhattan Bridge ▶ 5:07
Jon recommends walking the Manhattan Bridge because you can stare at the Brooklyn Bridge from there.
- Central Park ▶ 6:19
Both agree it's not overrated: it has the iconic cityscape views, peaceful pockets, and was designed to look like great European paintings, so photos look like a fairyland.
- Prospect Park ▶ 6:19
Mentioned as the park Brooklyn locals claim is better than Central Park, a claim the hosts dismiss.
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art ▶ 7:13
Not overrated: at $30 it holds works you can't find anywhere else, you could spend a whole day there, and its rooftop bar has the best views of Central Park from above (though the drinks are overpriced).
- Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree ▶ 8:20
Jon calls it overrated: it's super crowded the whole time it's up, looks the same every year, and isn't even the best Christmas tree in the city; see it from afar and get out.
- Saks Fifth Avenue ▶ 8:56
Suggested as a quick stop near the Rockefeller tree to see the Saks Fifth Avenue light show before leaving the chaos.
- The High Line ▶ 9:13
Not overrated and free: an elevated former railroad track with art displays and good history, best walked from the Meatpacking District to Hudson Yards, ideally in spring or right at opening/closing.
- Meatpacking District ▶ 9:48
Named as where the High Line walk starts before ending at the Vessel and Hudson Yards.
- Hudson Yards ▶ 9:48
The endpoint of the High Line walk, where you arrive at the Vessel.
- The Vessel ▶ 9:48
Mentioned as the landmark you reach at the end of walking the High Line into Hudson Yards.
- Chelsea Market ▶ 10:19
Suggested as a stop at the end of the High Line; it used to be the Nabisco factory where Oreos were made.