I Tested Every Fast Food Chain in New York
Jon Barr ·
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- McDonald's ▶ 0:17
The presenters use two Quarter Pounders from McDonald's as a baseline, timing the order at 4 minutes 23 seconds and giving it a B-minus.
- Nathan's Famous ▶ 0:34
They visit a Nathan's location, noting the chain opened in 1916 in Coney Island, Brooklyn, and get charged $7 for a hot dog they call an F.
- 7th Street Burger ▶ 1:58
The newest chain on the list, opened in 2021, is praised for its onion-heavy smash burgers and earns a solid B.
- Joe's Pizza ▶ 3:27
They visit the Times Square location of Joe's Pizza, the famous chain founded in 1975 with its original on Carmine Street, and give the slice a B-plus.
- The Halal Guys ▶ 4:51
The OG of New York halal food, established in 1990, gets a fast 2 minute 40 second order but the chicken and lamb disappoint, scoring a D and a high C.
- Los Tacos No. 1 ▶ 6:31
Founded in 2013 in Chelsea Market, this taco spot earns an A for its juicy meat, hand-rolled corn tortillas and great salsa, becoming the video's winner.
- 2 Bros Pizza ▶ 7:38
The dollar-slice icon opened in the East Village in 2007; now $1.50, the slice gets a D and a C-minus for salty, greasy cheese.
- Sticky's Finger Joint ▶ 9:18
The chicken finger chain earns an A-minus for its well-seasoned, saucy tenders, though the presenters note its NYC locations closed for good days after filming.
- Ess-a-Bagel ▶ 10:08
The bagel chain established in 1976 gets a B for its light, doughy, chewy plain bagel with cream cheese, which they call the Joe's Pizza of bagels.
- 16 Handles ▶ 11:31
The self-serve frozen yogurt chain founded in 2008 gets a B-minus and C-plus; the interactive DIY experience is fun but the ice cream is only okay.
- Shake Shack ▶ 13:14
Founded in 2001 in Madison Square Park as a hot dog cart, Shake Shack's Shack Burger earns an A-minus for its quality, balance and texture.