Trying 16 Buffalo Wing Spots in 24 Hours to Find the Best One | Taste Of The Town | Bon Appétit
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- La Nova ▶ 0:15
The first stop, known for its barbecue wing made through a five-step fry, sauce, and grill process; the medium Buffalo wings cost $19 for 10.
- Gabriel's Gate ▶ 2:07
A locally loved spot where the wings are bigger and the sauce is better balanced, with a full-mouth spice; 10 wings for $19.95.
- Anchor Bar ▶ 3:33
One of the places claiming to have invented the Buffalo wing; a Buffalo institution with a vinegary kick, though the blue cheese tastes almost like ranch. 10 wings for $16.99.
- Forty Thieves ▶ 4:53
All sauces and blue cheese are homemade; the wings have a peppery, slightly sweet flavor and become the tentative best of the day at $17 for 10.
- Kelly's Korner ▶ 6:18
A locally beloved dive; the to-go wings look barely sauced, are salty and heavy on vinegar, and rank on the lower end. $17 inside, $18 to go.
- Duff's Famous Wings ▶ 7:23
A legendary spot that followed Anchor Bar; the medium is good but not as hot as advertised, with a nice blue cheese funk. 10 wings for $16.99.
- Wingnutz ▶ 8:44
A fan favorite where the couple has perfected wings for over 10 years; super saucy, perfectly cooked, and close to the platonic ideal of a classic wing. $20 for 10.
- Gene McCarthy's ▶ 10:05
Known for dry-rubbed wings, but the medium Buffalo wings are lightly sauced, herby, and tangy, a sliver less exciting than Wingnutz.
- Doc Sullivan's ▶ 11:10
Famous for the South Buffalo Smitty wing, with 20 herbs and spices mixed into the butter, giving a smoky, warm-spiced flavor. $17 for 10.
- Adolf's ▶ 12:16
Smitty-inspired wings with a secret spice blend and the best blue cheese dip of the tour; $15 for 10, and ultimately named the best wing in Buffalo.
- Nine-Eleven Tavern ▶ 13:35
The only spot with a line out the door; named for its address, it only does mild, medium, and hot wings, which are artfully plated and sweeter than classic. $15.95 for 10.
- Bar-Bill Tavern ▶ 15:29
A packed crowd favorite where wings are painted with sauce by brush; the medium is genuinely spicy and smoky, a real contender for number one. $16.95 for 10.
- Glen Park Tavern ▶ 16:54
A cozy spot with long-tenured staff and high vibes; the wings are crispy but not spicy, and the menu lists wings at market price, currently $15.95 for eight.
- Elmo's ▶ 18:00
Too full to sit inside, so the wings were eaten outside; the classic Buffalo is heavy on vinegar with tender meat, though Elmo's is really known for double-dipped grilled wings. $16 for 10.
- Cole's ▶ 19:09
A staple near the college campus; the wings are well-sauced but among the saltiest of the night, with a punchy white vinegar flavor. $17.99 for 10.
- Mr. Goodbar ▶ 19:57
A college bar with darts, pool, and TVs; the cheapest wings of the night at $12 for 10, thoroughly sauced and vinegary but very standard.