Exuma: Swimming Pigs, Boat Charters & Who Should Skip It
Phil and H Travel Podcast - Is It Worth It? ·
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Exuma ▶ 0:52
The whole episode audits Exuma in the Bahamas, weighing the swimming pigs, sandbars and charter boats against the island's hidden costs and logistics.
- Exuma International Airport ▶ 2:56
A private consortium secured a 50-year concession to operate Exuma's airport and is reportedly introducing steep new passenger fees starting January 2027.
- Sandals Emerald Bay ▶ 5:59
The island's only large resort closed in August 2024 with no reopening date, wiping out 425 jobs and destabilizing the whole island's supply chain.
- Staniel Cay Airport ▶ 8:39
The presenter warns that Staniel Cay Airport is closed from September 21 to October 31, 2026, forcing flights to divert through Blackpoint and breaking itineraries to the Exuma Cays.
- Exuma Watersports ▶ 10:13
The top-rated excursion company halts most services in September and keeps staff only for boat maintenance; it publishes exact prices, $175 for a 4-hour local trip and $435 for the 8-hour run to the Keys.
- George Town ▶ 16:40
The presenter says you must base yourself in George Town on Great Exuma because it holds the grocery stores, clinics and primary road network, and almost every marine operator leaves from there.
- Thompson's Rentals ▶ 19:34
Only one rental firm publishes a full daily tariff, from $60 a day for a small Honda up to $250 for a Suburban.
- Grand Isle Resort ▶ 23:33
The presenter says Grand Isle lists eight packages but hides its base nightly rate behind the booking portal, with aggregators estimating $750 to $1,250 a night.
- Augusta Bay ▶ 23:33
One of the traditional hotels that hides its rates; aggregators put it roughly between $230 and $400 a night.
- Hideaways at Palm Bay ▶ 23:33
Listed among the traditional properties with no published base rates, tracking at $210 to $470 a night on aggregators.
- Peace and Plenty ▶ 23:43
Named among the traditional properties that publish zero base nightly rates on their websites.
- Snappy Turtle ▶ 27:15
Used as a transparent case study: its menu states prices exclude 10% VAT and 15% gratuity, so a $42 cracked conch actually costs $52.50.
- Coastline Adventures ▶ 27:53
One of the few operators detailing fees: base prices exclude 10% VAT, credit cards add 5%, and there is a $15 per person cash landing fee for the nurse sharks at Compass Cay; rated 4.5 from 750 reviews at $300 per adult.
- Compass Cay ▶ 28:10
The marina where you wade with nurse sharks; it publishes no fee schedule, and dock workers demand arbitrary cash amounts, from $10 a person to $280 for a 45-minute visit.
- Off Island Boat Tours ▶ 35:26
Its $700 charter is a localized 8-hour tour around Great Exuma, Moriah Harbour and Stocking Island, with sandbars and turtles but no pigs.
- Moriah Harbour Cay ▶ 35:27
Named as one of the stops on the affordable 8-hour local boat tour around Great Exuma.
- Stocking Island ▶ 35:35
A stop on the local boat tour; it holds a 4.6 rating but relies on water taxis from George Town that publish no timetable, so you must ask the captain verbally.
- Big Major Cay ▶ 35:43
Home of the famous swimming pigs, 40 miles north of Great Exuma; the Pig Beach listing sits at 4.2 from 251 reviews, with aggressive pigs and heavy boat traffic.
- Thunderball Grotto ▶ 35:58
A submerged cave rated 4.7 from 400 reviews, but currents at high tide can rip fins off your feet, so go only at low tide or stay out of the water.
- Tar Bay ▶ 40:39
Site of a July 2025 incident where an American snorkeling 20 feet from shore was struck by a speeding commercial boat and airlifted to Miami.
- Robert's Island Adventures ▶ 46:11
One of the operators clearing the reliability bar, holding 4.8 from roughly 700 reviews and charging about $38 for a Keys trip.
- Coco Plum Beach ▶ 46:35
Rated 4.7 and visually stunning, but only worth visiting at low tide when its huge sandbar lets you walk hundreds of yards into ankle-deep water.
- Tropic of Cancer Beach ▶ 47:07
A 4.8-rated beach reached via a deeply rutted unpaved road that risks undercarriage damage in a low-clearance compact car.
- Santana's ▶ 48:04
The highest-rated local restaurant on the island, but it is cash only, lunch only and closed on Sundays, which is the heart of the Sunday trap.
- Tropic Breeze ▶ 48:31
One of the best culinary options in George Town, but it is closed Sunday and Monday.
- Sandpiper Cafe ▶ 48:36
Shuts down at 3:00 p.m., so it is not an option for a late Sunday meal.
- Shoreline Beach Club ▶ 48:38
Closed Sunday and Tuesday, adding to the Sunday trap in George Town.
- Bitter Guana Cay ▶ 51:59
Its iguanas fed by tourists show cholesterol of 89 versus 35 in the wild and a 100% parasite infection rate, and tourists have been filmed dragging them by the tails.
- Chat 'N' Chill ▶ 53:19
On Stocking Island, rated 4.2 from 1,900 reviews but described as a captive tourist trap with notoriously bad service; go for the stingrays, not the food.
- Nassau ▶ 54:42
Suggested as a logistical hub: a commercial operator runs high-speed day boats from Nassau to the Exuma Cays for a transparent $750 to $850 all-inclusive rate.
- Eleuthera ▶ 55:59
Offered as an alternative for a quiet beach and beautiful water, with the same logistical friction but better culinary infrastructure and famous pink sand beaches.
- Harbour Island ▶ 55:59
Paired with Eleuthera as an alternative for travelers who want quiet beaches and pink sand rather than the wildlife.
Cities in these videos
Exuma · Staniel Cay · George Town · Little Exuma · Nassau · Eleuthera · Harbour Island