Is this the BEST Pizza in New York City?
Open in PlaceTube Watch on YouTube
Places in this video
- Luigi's Pizza ▶ 0:32
The first stop of the pizza crawl, a Brooklyn pizzeria open since 1973 and featured in the movie Big Daddy. They rate the pepperoni slice very highly, around 8.5-8.7.
- L'Industrie Pizzeria ▶ 2:08
Described as often voted one of the best pizza places in New York City, where they tried pepperoni and a prosciutto and burrata slice. They call it the best slice of their lives so far, scoring around 9.2-9.3.
- Little Italy ▶ 3:32
They detour into Little Italy in Manhattan, walking the streets and stopping for cannoli and espresso before continuing the pizza crawl.
- Cannoli King ▶ 4:04
A cannoli stop in Little Italy whose signs claim the best cannoli in the United States; the presenter thought it was fantastic.
- Chinatown ▶ 4:35
They pass through Chinatown after Little Italy, getting distracted by the fish markets along the way.
- Scarr's Pizza ▶ 4:35
A Lower Manhattan pizzeria where they liked the herby sauce and different cheese, plus a hot honey slice. They score it around 8.8, just above Luigi's.
- Lombardi's Pizza ▶ 5:41
Known as America's first pizzeria, founded in 1905, though it moved about a block from the original location. They get a full pie with fresh cheese, basil and pepperoni and call it a taste of history, scoring around 8.7-8.8.
- Prince Street Pizza ▶ 7:34
An influencer-loved spot known for its square spicy pepperoni slices, which they try but don't include in the ratings since it's a different style.
- West Village ▶ 8:36
Called a mecca for pizza in New York City, with four top spots within a couple of blocks.
- Mama's Too! ▶ 8:36
A West Village pizzeria whose classic pepperoni uses a vodka sauce, giving it a unique flavor; they score it around 8.7-8.8.
- Bleecker Street Pizza ▶ 9:22
A tiny, high-volume spot on Bleecker Street with a cheesy, greasy classic New York slice; they score it around 8.5-8.7.
- John's of Bleecker Street ▶ 11:34
Open since 1929, a quintessential old-school pizza place with tile floors and booths where you buy a whole pie. They love the saucy, chewy pizza, scoring it around 8.75-9.0.
- Joe's Pizza ▶ 13:27
A classic slice shop open since 1975, which the presenter had visited about 10 years earlier. They call it a solid classic slice with a good sauce-to-cheese ratio, scoring around 8.2-8.5.
- Juliana's Pizza ▶ 14:33
A highly recommended spot in Dumbo, Brooklyn, where they order a to-go pie and an egg cream and have the family review the pizza, scoring around 8.5-9.1.
- Dumbo ▶ 14:49
Called probably their favorite place in New York, where they spent lots of time while living in Brooklyn and end the night with family.
- Lucali ▶ 16:24
Supposedly the best pizza in all of New York, but with crazy waits; after a two-hour wait for a table and 45 minutes for food, they call it an incredible slice and recommend the calzone.